RCM Vendors: How to Compare Them Before You Sign
By Robert Del Grande · November 18, 2026 · 7 min read
The short answer
RCM vendors fall into three types: software you run yourself, a full outsourced billing team, or a mix of both inside one system. The right fit depends on how much billing work your practice wants to keep in house versus hand off. This post walks through what to check before you choose an RCM vendor, and how billing differs for a dental claim versus a medical or chiropractic claim.
When a practice looks for rcm vendors, they are really choosing who runs claims, coding, and collections day to day. Some vendors sell software a practice runs itself. Some sell a team that runs the work for the practice. Many blend the two. Below is what each type actually does, what to check before signing with any vendor, and how billing differs for a dental claim versus a medical or chiropractic claim.
What Does an RCM Vendor Actually Do?
An RCM vendor is a company that handles some or all of the billing work behind patient care: checking insurance before the visit, coding the claim correctly, filing it electronically, posting what the payer pays, following up on claims that sit unpaid, and fixing denials so the practice gets paid for the work it already did. Some RCM vendors sell software only, and the practice's own staff runs every step inside it. Some RCM vendors sell a billing team that runs those steps for the practice, inside the same software the practice can see into. Many practices use a mix: front desk staff run insurance checks themselves, while a billing team handles claim submission, payment posting, and denial follow-up. The mix that fits one practice does not fit another, and the right choice depends on how much billing work the practice wants to keep in house versus hand off.
Software, Outsourced Teams, or Both
Vendors in this space generally fall into two camps, with most practices landing somewhere in between. Some vendors sell revenue cycle management software only: the practice's own front desk and billing staff log in and run every step themselves, from checking insurance to posting payments. Other vendors sell full revenue cycle management services, where a dedicated team runs claims, follow-up, and appeals for the practice inside the vendor's own system. A smaller office with one or two billers often wants a vendor that can flex between the two: run the easy claims in house and hand off the backlog when a biller is out or a denial pile builds up.
Software-only vendors usually focus hardest on the front end of the cycle, like insurance verification, since that is the step a front desk can run in a few minutes between patients. The ADA Health Policy Institute found that 43.3% of dentists use AI for at least one task in their practice, and insurance verification is the second most common planned use, with 32.6% of dentists planning to use it against 13.6% who already do. That gap between what is planned and what is actually running is worth asking about directly with any vendor.
If a practice is weighing a full outsourced team instead of software, it helps to see what that arrangement actually looks like day to day, including who answers when a payer calls back with a question. We cover that in what an outsourced medical billing company does.
How to Compare RCM Vendors Before You Sign
A few questions separate a vendor that fits a single-location practice from one built for a hospital system:
- Software, service, or both? Ask whether staff run the work themselves, a vendor team runs it, or either option is available.
- Electronic claims only? Claims that go out electronically move through a clearinghouse in minutes; paper claims add days before a payer even logs them.
- Who checks the codes? Ask whether someone reviews codes for mismatches or a missing modifier before a claim goes out, or whether that catch falls on the practice alone.
- How fast is payment posted? Once a payer answers, find out how quickly what they paid, and what the patient owes, lands on the claim.
- Who follows up on open claims? Ask whether the vendor follows up on every open claim with the payer, or only the ones the practice flags.
- What does a denial actually show? A useful denial view shows the payer's reason and the fix, not just a denial code to look up elsewhere.
- Can you see your own numbers? Ask for reporting on what was billed, paid, and still owed, by claim and by payer, any time you want to look.
- Is there a signed BAA? Valian signs a business associate agreement (BAA) with every practice, and any vendor handling patient data should be willing to put that in writing too.
We put together a longer checklist, with contract terms and implementation timelines, in what to check first with a revenue cycle management vendor.
Medical Billing vs Dental Billing: Why the Claim Form Matters
Not every RCM vendor handles every claim form, and that matters more than most vendor comparisons mention. Chiropractic claims and medical claims, including family practice, cardiology, and endocrinology, all go out on the CMS-1500 form, using CPT and ICD-10 codes. Dental claims go out on a different form entirely, the ADA dental claim form, using CDT codes instead. A vendor built around CMS-1500 claims may not have dental coding or the ADA form built into its software at all, and the reverse is true for a vendor built only for dental offices. Before signing with any vendor, ask directly which claim forms its software and its billing team actually handle today, not just which specialties are listed on its website. Denial management works differently depending on the claim form too; we cover how that works in how healthcare denial management software works.
How Valian Fits Into This Picture
At Valian, we built one piece of software that covers each of these pieces instead of splitting them across separate tools. The front desk signs in and checks a patient's insurance in one click, and gets the payer's answer in seconds. Our own team runs prior authorization requests and tracks each one with the payer directly, so the practice is not stuck on hold. For coding, the doctor picks the codes, and Valian checks them before the claim goes out, catching codes that do not belong together or a missing modifier.
Medical and chiropractic claims are built in the Valian dashboard and sent electronically, with every claim reviewed before it goes. Once a payer answers, we post what they paid and what the patient still owes straight to the claim, follow up on every open claim with the payer, and show the payer's reason and the fix on anything that comes back denied. e-Reporting shows what was billed, paid, and still owed, by claim and by payer, any time the practice wants to look. All of this sits inside our medical billing services, whether a practice runs it themselves or hands it to our team.
Your billing, streamlined in our software. Keep managing it yourself, or have us take it over.
If you want to walk through your own claims and see how the comparison looks for your practice, Book a discovery call.